X-Git-Url: https://sipb.mit.edu/gitweb.cgi/ikiwiki.git/blobdiff_plain/fc268b311d8d9ac28a0f52cbede79fde18c6cd47..19b9328520487f8682567cc871289fb4ebee9f00:/doc/bugs/feedpages_does_not_prevent_tags_from_being_aggregated.mdwn

diff --git a/doc/bugs/feedpages_does_not_prevent_tags_from_being_aggregated.mdwn b/doc/bugs/feedpages_does_not_prevent_tags_from_being_aggregated.mdwn
index d00e6b8ef..a004154df 100644
--- a/doc/bugs/feedpages_does_not_prevent_tags_from_being_aggregated.mdwn
+++ b/doc/bugs/feedpages_does_not_prevent_tags_from_being_aggregated.mdwn
@@ -1,11 +1,32 @@
 I added a feedpages directive to `blog/index.mdwn` to not pick up anything tagged `tags/random/hidden` yet that still happenend.
 
     ~git/richardhartmann.de/blog % grep hidden index.mdwn
-    [[!inline pages="./posts/*/*/* and !*/Discussion" feedpages="./posts/*/*/* and !*/Discussion and not tagged(tags/random/hidden)" show="10" actions=yes rootpage="blog"]]
+    \[[!inline pages="./posts/*/*/* and !*/Discussion" feedpages="./posts/*/*/* and !*/Discussion and not tagged(tags/random/hidden)" show="10" actions=yes rootpage="blog"]]
     ~git/richardhartmann.de/blog % grep hidden posts/2013/05/17-Debian_Release_Critical_Bug_report_for_Week_20.mdwn
-    [[!tag tags/tech/floss/debian tags/tech/floss/debian/rc-stats/8.0-jessie tags/random/hidden]]
+    \[[!tag tags/tech/floss/debian tags/tech/floss/debian/rc-stats/8.0-jessie tags/random/hidden]]
     ~git/richardhartmann.de/blog %
 
 If you need more information, please let me know.
 
 Richard
+
+> I don't think this is a bug. You have a syntax error in your pagespec:
+> "not" is not a recognised keyword in [[pagespecs|ikiwiki/pagespec]],
+> so `and not tagged(...)` should be `and !tagged(...)`. Presumably inline
+> falls back to `pages` when `feedpages` doesn't work.
+>
+> By posting the pagespec here with insufficient escaping (which I've fixed)
+> you caused *this* ikiwiki instance's HTML to contain an error message
+> illustrating that syntax error :-)
+>
+>     <span class="error">Error: syntax error in pagespec "(./posts/*/*/* and !*/Discussion) and (./posts/*/*/* and !*/Discussion and not tagged(tags/random/hidden))"</span>
+>
+> [[done]]. --[[smcv]]
+
+> > As per IRC: Thanks. As an aside, shouldn't this ikiwiki instance ignore directives in normal text? The problem may be non-trivial, but still... -- Richard
+
+>>> "Normal text" is exactly where directives go, so, not really.
+>>> If you mean verbatim text (e.g. indentation in Markdown): the fact that
+>>> directives still expand to HTML, which is then treated as verbatim, is an
+>>> unfortunate result of how ikiwiki interacts with pages' markup languages
+>>> (directives and wikilinks happen before markup is converted to HTML). --[[smcv]]