sign my change

[ikiwiki.git] / doc / todo / Allow_disabling_edit_and_preferences_links.mdwn

diff --git a/doc/todo/Allow_disabling_edit_and_preferences_links.mdwn b/doc/todo/Allow_disabling_edit_and_preferences_links.mdwn
index 10eae35a79d9315264063a86932209bf2a496aec..17f45dda6771fd519a8bee23ba292823a98a9470 100644 (file)
--- a/doc/todo/Allow_disabling_edit_and_preferences_links.mdwn
+++ b/doc/todo/Allow_disabling_edit_and_preferences_links.mdwn
@@ -25,3 +25,57 @@ Patch:
         }
 
 </pre>
+
+> On irc, you said, "That was to allow the hack to of using wikistatedir to
+> allow me to generate two websites, one with inline editting, the other a
+> static page for public consumption."
+> 
+> The edit and preferences links can already be disabled by editing
+> `page.tmpl`. (Look for PREFSURL and EDITURL).
+> 
+> More to the point though, disabling those links does not disable anyone
+> consticting the urls by hand and logging in and editing a page. So you'd
+> really want to disable the editpage plugin in the setup file for the
+> public, static wiki. Sounds like you might also want to turn off cgi
+> entirely for that build. --[[Joey]] 
+
+>> I want to retain the same page.tmpl for both sites (different templates
+>> will just increase the maintenance hell), so disabling the links in the
+>> config for one public site works better in my case.
+>>
+>> I do have the editpage plugin disabled for the public static wiki, but
+>> the link still appears on the site.  I want to keep the cgi on, so that
+>> the site is still searchable. --[[puck]]
+
+>>> For me, disabling the editpage plugin does make the "Edit" link
+>>> disappear (this is with 3.03) but as far as I can tell, "Preferences"
+>>> is not controlled by any plugin.  It would be nice if it were; I am
+>>> trying to achieve a configuration where the only action supported
+>>> via CGI is blog-style comments.  --[Zack](http://zwol.livejournal.com/)
+
+>>> Like [[puck]], I'd like to keep search available but I want to disable all
+>>> login facitilities and thus disable the "Preferences" link.
+>>>
+>>> After digging a little bit in the source code, my first attempt was to make
+>>> the "Preferences" link appear only if there is `sessioncgi` hooks
+>>> registered.  But this will not work as the [[plugins/inline]] plugin also
+>>> defines it.
+>>>
+>>> Looking for `auth` hooks currently would not work as at least
+>>> [[plugins/passwordauth]] does not register one.
+>>>
+>>> Adding a new `canlogin` hook looks like overkill to me.  [[Joey]], how
+>>> about making registration of the `auth` hook mandatory for all plugins
+>>> making sense of the "Preferences" link? --[[Lunar]]
+
+>>>> Hmm, using the `auth` hook existance does seem like a nice solution.
+>>>> While splitting the preferences code out into its own plugin is
+>>>> easily enough done, it has the minor problem of being yet another
+>>>> file nearly all ikiwikis will have to load, and also, prefs would
+>>>> have to be disabled manually. So I like that using the hook would
+>>>> cause it to auto-disable if nothing uses it. It's a bit ugly that
+>>>> passwordauth doesn't need an auth hook (it could be reorged to
+>>>> use it instead of formbuilder, maybe) and would probably just have an
+>>>> empty one. Thanks for the idea. --[[Joey]]  [[done]]
+
+>>>>> Thanks for implementing it! --[[Lunar]]