web commit by http://ryan.idletheme.org/: updated patch

[ikiwiki.git] / doc / todo / format_escape.mdwn

diff --git a/doc/todo/format_escape.mdwn b/doc/todo/format_escape.mdwn
index 13f211d1eda0d55e705067b3ce376ebb644eb2ef..7c9a7f1ecadf5d7e1e10425a08b84cb2ef810a3c 100644 (file)
--- a/doc/todo/format_escape.mdwn
+++ b/doc/todo/format_escape.mdwn
@@ -47,6 +47,55 @@ which aren't used as real extensions but provide useful intermediate types.
 
 --[[JeremieKoenig]]
 
+> Wow, this is in many ways a beautiful patch. I did notice one problem,
+> if a link is converted to rst and then from there to a hyperlink, the
+> styling info usially added to such a link is lost. I wonder if it would
+> be better to lose _link stuff and just create link html that is fed into
+> the rst,html converter. Other advantage to doing that is that link
+> creation has a rather complex interface, with selflink, attrs, url, and
+> content parameters.
+> 
+> --[[Joey]]
+
+>> Thanks for the compliment. I must confess that I'm not too familiar with
+>> rst. I am using this todo item somewhat as a pretext to get the conversion
+>> stuff in, which I need to implement some other stuff. As a result I was
+>> less careful with the rst plugin than with the rest of the patch.
+>> I just updated the patch to fix some other problems which I found with
+>> more testing, and document the current limitations.
+
+>> Rst cannot embed raw html in the middle of a paragraph, which is why
+>> "_link" was necessary. Rst links are themselves tricky and can't be made to
+>> work inside of words without knowledge about the context.
+>> Both problems could be fixed by inserting marks instead of the html/link,
+>> which would be replaced at a later stage (htmlize, format), somewhat
+>> similiar to the way the toc plugin works. When I get more time I will
+>> try to fix the remaining glitches this way.
+
+>> Also, I think it would be useful if ikiwiki had an option to export
+>> the preprocessed source. This way you can use docutils to convert your
+>> rst documents to other formats. Raw html would be loosed in such a
+>> process (both with directives and marks), which is another
+>> argument for `"_link"` and other intermediate forms. I think I can
+>> come up with a way for rst's convert_link to be used only for export
+>> purposes, though.
+
+>> --[[JeremieKoenig]]
+
+> Another problem with this approach is when there is some html (say a
+> table), that contains a wikilink. If the link is left up to the markup
+> lamguage to handle, it will never convert it to a link, since the table
+> will be processed as a chunk of raw html.
+> --[[Joey]]
+
+### Updated patch
+
+I've created an updated [patch](http://www.idletheme.org/code/patches/ikiwiki-format-escapes-rlk-2007-09-24.diff) against the current revision.  No real functionality changes, except for a small test script, one minor bugfix (put a "join" around a scalar-context "map" in convert_link), and some wrangling to get it merged properly; I thought it might be helpful for anyone else who wants to work on the code.
+
+(With that out of the way, I think I'm going to take a stab at Jeremie's plan to use marks which would be replaced post-htmlization.  I've also got an eye towards [[todo/multiple_output_formats]].)
+
+--Ryan Koppenhaver
+
 ## Original patch
 [[tag patch]]